![]() |
James Cowan, 2008 |
In the evening before each class, I write out my final lesson plan, the list of teaching points and excercises I want to cover the next day. But as I settle into life as a university lecturer, I’m learning classrooms are great places for improv.
Take today’s class, which focused on techniques for interviewing eyewitnesses. In the lesson plan, I plotted out a relatively simple activity to introduce the topic. I divided the class in two, keeping half of the students in the room and sending the others outside to relax for a couple of minutes in the bright morning sun. I then put on a little show for the students still in the room: sitting down and standing up repeatedly, balancing on one leg, moving furniture and dropping my notebook to the ground. When I finished, I called the other students back inside and told them to interview their compatriots about what just happened. The idea was to illustrate the unreliability of eyewitnesses and open a discussion about interviewing techniques.
All went according to plan, until I asked the reporters to share what they had learned.
“Share or show?” asked one of the students.
Share, I clarified, before realizing that showing might make more sense — and be funnier as well. And so, three of the reporters took a turn at the front of the class, doing their best to recreate my variety act. Even one of the eyewitnesses took the stage, but none of them came close to correctly portraying the sequence of events. Even the small variations were instructive. Some gently placed my notebook on the floor while others slammed it down with a vicious “thump.” Some sat down for just a second while others lingered for close to a minute. When the performaces were finished, we had an energetic discussion about the limitations of eyewitness accounts and how to overcome them, followed by a quick review of basic interviewing skills.
The lesson proved instructive for both my students and myself. The slight change in my plan meant even the students who struggle with English could glean something from the class, thanks to the performances of their classmates.
Writing teachers often instruct their students to “show, don’t tell.” More and more, I’m learning it is advice for teachers to heed as well.


